Skip to content
Theme
OnDevice Tools

AndroidAndroid Apps

Facebook Android gallery: Italy fines Meta €805 million

The Garante says the Android app accessed photos and videos without specific consent. Meta plans to appeal and has 60 days to change the feature in Italy.

Illustration of a Facebook app on an Android phone showing a photo gallery permission warning

Key takeaways

  • The Garante fined Meta €805 million over Facebook Android gallery suggestions.
  • The regulator says the app accessed photos and videos without specific consent.
  • Meta has 60 days to seek separate consent and leave the feature disabled by default in Italy.
  • Meta plans to appeal, and the orders apply only in Italy.
In this article
  1. What the Garante decided
  2. Legal basis and jurisdiction
  3. How the Android feature worked
  4. What Meta must change in Italy
  5. How to turn off camera roll suggestions

What the Garante decided

The Garante set out the decision in a statement dated 14 November 2026. It says Meta obtained access to photos, videos and related metadata without asking for specific permission. It also says users were not given proper information about that access.

Notebookcheck reports that the case concerns the Facebook app on Android. The regulator says the app showed gallery items while people scrolled and suggested posting them. It treats this as access to a person's private space.

The Garante relied on the ePrivacy Directive, an EU privacy rule as implemented in Italian law. Under that rule, access to material stored on a smartphone requires consent that is freely given and informed. The regulator says this applies even if data stays on the device and no harm is shown.

Meta said the Irish regulator should deal with the case. The Garante rejected that view because the ePrivacy rules do not provide a single lead regulator system. Notebookcheck says this means cross-border cases can be handled by more than one authority.

The penalty is based on about 20 million Android users affected in Italy. Notebookcheck says the sum also takes account of an earlier Meta case from 2019 and limited cooperation. That is about 0.47% of Meta's worldwide revenue.

This is not Meta's first European fine. In December 2024, the Irish data regulator ordered a €251 million payment over a 2018 Facebook security breach.

How the Android feature worked

The suggestion feature has been available since 2023. As users browse Facebook, it can display images and videos from the phone's photo library and propose sharing them. Notebookcheck says the feature was enabled by default.

Facebook asks for gallery access with a single app-wide permission. The advance notice says the permission will enable other features. It does not mention the suggestions. After full approval, the app can keep reading the full photo library over time.

The Garante says users and the regulator cannot see what is actually used. That lack of visibility is central to the decision. The case did not cover artificial intelligence training, which Meta denies.

What Meta must change in Italy

Illustration: Meta logo, settings, camera, update and the labels Android, EU, Facebook

Meta has 60 days to seek separate consent for the feature. It must explain clearly what the feature does and leave it disabled by default. This also applies to people who already gave gallery access.

The orders are limited to Italy. The feature is also present in other countries. In April, Meta began a wider release of a version that processes the camera roll in the cloud, meaning on remote servers, in the EU and the UK.

That version is opt-in. This means users must choose to enable it. It uses artificial intelligence from Meta to create collages and edits from the camera roll, or photo library.

The Garante will examine this newer feature in a separate process. The current case is limited to the older gallery suggestion feature. No decision on that version is included in the current case.

How to turn off camera roll suggestions

Users can disable the basic suggestions from the Facebook app menu. In Settings & privacy, open Settings and disable camera roll suggestions. Facebook's help center says this choice covers all devices where Facebook can access photos.

A stronger option is to change the Android permission. Android users can open Apps, then Facebook, then Permissions. They can restrict photo and video access to selected items or remove it. This controls access through Android rather than only inside the app.

Meta plans to appeal the fine, according to Notebookcheck. The company called the fine disproportionate. The Garante's decision shows that access to a phone's stored media can be regulated as a privacy issue.

Sources

  1. Facebook: Italy fines Meta €805 million over Android gallery accessNotebookcheck

Tags

Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.